Can we ask such Questions?

[Big Deal]

Quoting Fact Heart:

For example; sometimes people asking where god is exist?


Plus the question is one of the Questions aren't ours, i mean we are not suppose to ask that. If we ask for the place so that will be direct words that god need a place to site... sub7an allah. Allah "kamel" ....> perfect.

There have been many questions similar to this, that i would discuss with my friends about sometimes, like "Where does god exist?" or "Why didn't god make everyone pure at heart, why doesn't god get rid of satan and evil" .. I am not looking answers for these questions in specific, and when i discussed this with my friends, we were not questioning gods abilities, we were just curious human beings.

So can we ask such questions? (Asta'3farlaah if it was wrong to say those things above)

On the contrary, if it is wrong to do so, some would argue, why would god give us the intelligence to think about it if its wrong.

[Fact HearT]

As I mentioned in your other thread we shouldn't ask such Qs. the reason as above

سبحانه, كان ولا مكانَ ، وهو على ما كانَ ، قبل خلق المكانِ ، لم يتغير عن ما كانَ ، علمَ ما كانَ ، وعلم ما يكونُ ، وعلمَ ما سيكونُ ، لو كانَ كيف كان يكونَ


god is around with out a place to site, he looks at us with out needing eyes, he hears us with out needing ears, he talks to us with out needing tongue

And for your other Q; God can get rid of them " satan and evil" why can't he !!

He can force what ever he want, But he gives humans choices with clarification " the right from the wrong"

[Big Deal]

^ i get what you are saying fact heart...but i honestly dont want this thread to be about those 2 questions i asked xD

but thanks for your input

[Abu Eliyas]

really i don't know but am sure the holy quran will have reply about what you ask

[Cherry]

I think its normal as well as OK to ask 'why..!' and wonder about this world that we are living in. We are encouraged to look for knowledge in islam BUT we must not forget that we need to have faith in what & how Allah created us.
sooner or later the information that you have been wondering about will come to you... and suddenly it would all make sense.

what is wrong is to doubt His creation. But to question 'why' I think its okay.. because eventually there is a reason for everything and Allah knows best.

[El Rey]

I don't think it's harm to think about Allah from to time to another, BUT first you have to know that as you have a limited sight, hearing etc.. You also have a limited thinking. Our minds don't comprehend everything specially things that we never seen and are beyond our thinking. I think about God as well but when I begin torecognize that I started to drift away I just stop cos it may be a negative thinking and or prophet :PBUH: told us that Satan comes from this gap to make us question God:

((يأتي الشيطان أحدكم فيقول من خلق كذا، من خلق كذا، حتى يقول من خلق ربك فإذا بلغه فليستعذ بالله ولينته)

Satan comes and ask people who created this and who created that till he says who created God, if it happened to you say a3ooth billah and stop it.

We just have to know when we ask about God that He told us something about him:

فَاطِرُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ جَعَلَ لَكُم مِّنْ أَنفُسِكُمْ أَزْوَاجًا وَمِنَ الْأَنْعَامِ أَزْوَاجًا يَذْرَؤُكُمْ فِيهِ لَيْسَ كَمِثْلِهِ شَيْءٌ وَهُوَ السَّمِيعُ البَصِيرُ

11. (He is) the Creator of the heavens and the earth: He has made for you pairs from among yourselves, and pairs among cattle: by this means does He multiply you: there is nothing whatever like unto Him, and He is the One that hears and sees (all things).

Allah gave us limited mind so we shouldn't give it more than it can handle, otherwise the consequences might be negative.

[Matiii]

god asked us to think and admire everything in the world
but when it comes to god, and where, nd how, and all the others question
we can't think of these question or to be clear the answers of these question
bcuz simply the human mind is not capable of thinking about these kind of stuff
cuz got made it limited (the thinking abilities of human beings)

[Blackout]

I trust in God and I am curious about the after life and scared too but I dont see myslef asking Canada's questions as of now when I became an adult. When I was a kid (which some of you may argue still am) I used to