zawag al mut3ah => temporary marraige for pleasure !!

[IceTea]

What do u think guys of "zawag al mut3ah" which means temporary marraige for pleasure ? According to "shi3a mathab" its halal so u can marry as u want temporary for 1 week or 2 weeks, etc just for the sake of pleasure !!!, but in fact its pure zena (adultry) and therefor its haram.

[amo0or]

ok..so what is the different between zina and zawaj el mut3ah???
in zawaj el mut3ah, the man and the lady knows that they'll get divorce after some few days!! and i think this is 7aram..coz as i heard that when el zawjeen known that they are going to divorce after some few days this is zawaj ba6il..coz then everyone will do it to whatever they want to do(which is sex) then finito!! i think this is 7aram and allah a3lam

[IceTea]

There is no difference between this type of marraige and adultry (zina), because zina is for the sake of having sex, enjoyment and in addition its like treating women like ****s. And its for few days and than they will leave eachother and they will start to have another temporary wife. And this is not the kind of marraige Allah permitted, the real marraige is more than the low level objective of this temporary marraige. Its meant for building a family, rasing kids and cooperation between the husband and his wife to live a happy life which also affect the whole society.

[NaBHaN]

....dunno if it's 7alal or 7aram , and i don't think that we have the right to judge each others believes, if the shia think it's ok to do so..then there must be a reason for it , and we can't just say it's zina..that way you're saying that the shia's are kuffar and are basicaly going to hell!!
anyways..i don't like the idea of marrige just for pleasure, and don;t approve of it!

[Bimzoori]

IceTea, I'm going to have to close this thread inorder to avoid any confusions as the same topic was opened earlier by AmoOor under the title "Halal or haram"

This is the link
Halal or Haram? (http://www.englishsabla.com/forum/showthread.php?threadid=6336)

I hope you can continue your discussions there..

Thank You..

:)