praying befor the call

[Abu Eliyas]

if you did praying then after you end the praying then hear the call for praying what do i have to do? do i need to pray again?

[Soulless]

xD back to islamic threads , alright umm which prayers and which call to prayers you heard ? o_O ?

[sameerb1]

all i know is you need to re-pray if you have prayed before Azaan...but i am trying to get the correct source to confirm...once i do i will get back to you again...but that's how far my information goes..

[sameerb1]

When the prayer time begins, a Muslim is permitted to perform the prayer, and the Aathaan is a sign that the prayer time started.

Therefore, a Muslim may perform the prayer as soon as he hears the Aathaan but it is preferable to repeat it as the Prophet ordered us to do so. Abdullaah Ibn Umar narrated that he heard the Prophet saying: ''When you hear the Muaththin (person calling Aathaan), you should repeat what he says, and then ask Allaah to exalt my mention, because whoever exalts my mention one time, Allaah will exalt his mention ten times, then ask Al-Waseelah (a very high rank in Paradise) for me, as only one of Allaah's Slaves deserves it and I hope that it will be me. Whoever asks Al-Waseelah for me, he will find my intercession.'' [ Muslim].

Allaah knows best.
http://www.islamweb.net/ver2/Fatwa/ShowFatwa.php?lang=E&Id=81403&Option=FatwaId


you can pray after you hear the sign being azan so before that salat could be invalid...

also



Performing a prayer right after hearing the Azan (call to prayer) is permissible, since the Azan is actually to inform people of starting the time of a prayer. As long as a Muezzin (caller to prayer) starts Azan it means the time of the prayer has started. But, it is desirable to listen to the entire Azan, to repeat it as the Muezzin calls, to supplicate the Prophetic Dua' after it, to invoke blessings upon the Prophet (Sallallahu Alaihi wa Sallam), and then, to perform the Sunnah prayer before the obligatory one. However, performing a prayer just after hearing the beginning of Azan is sufficient for one.

http://www.islamweb.net/ver2/Fatwa/ShowFatwa.php?lang=E&Id=83993&Option=FatwaId


so prayers should be after azan always...

now about what should you do if you have prayed before azan...i still cant find any material

[Abu Eliyas]

sameerb1 thanks for your help :)

i hope you will find same material or members will help so to find about before azan

[amo_l_oman]

Why did you pray before, if I may ask

[Abu Yahya]

May be he woke up before the call, and he thought it time to pray. It can happen to any one i guess if you dont know the Call timing and you dont have a watch.

[FAITH86]

As long as the time of prayer has started then you can pray, either you heard the Athan or not. Allah a3lam :p

[Storm]

AS far as I know - you need to re pray it once you hear the call.

Cause as I understand it - the call is the announcement of the time of that pray - if you pray it before it - then it is not it's time !

I hope I made my point clear !

[Abu Eliyas]

am looking for right proof :)

thanks to all

[Superbia]

I've done that many times, but I do not pray again. Why? Because I believe that your actions are weighed according to your intentions.

[Abu Eliyas]

I've done that many times, but I do not pray again. Why? Because I believe that your actions are weighed according to your intentions.

what if that not right

[NiGhTFaCe]

Take it by logic & sense, why would they call for a prayer when you can just pray it the time you want?!

[sameerb1]

I've done that many times, but I do not pray again. Why? Because I believe that your actions are weighed according to your intentions.

ya...but its clearly mentioned in my earlier proofs of ahadeeth, you should pray when the time of prayer started and it starts with the azan and not before azan...

if that hadeeth is true...then your prayer is invalid before azan...so you pray the fardh salaath again after azan

(and Allah knows best)

[Amjad]

ya...but its clearly mentioned in my earlier proofs of ahadeeth, you should pray when the time of prayer started and it starts with the azan and not before azan...

Not true.

The Athan starts when the time of prayer is there, but not the other way around. You can't go backward. When you hear the call of prayer (Athan) it tells you that it's already the time of prayer now. But, this time of prayer could have started five minutes before the Athan. The Athan is just there to confirm that it is indeed the time of prayer. The Athan cannot be performed before the time of prayer, but once the time of prayer is there, usually the Athan is performed a couple of minutes after it. But in order to be on the safe side, you should just follow the Athan and depend on it.

[sameerb1]

^okay...i agree with your point there...so again...to be on the safe side...

[Abu Eliyas]

no it is not oky what we need to know is if you pary befor athan do you need to pray again after you hear the athen this is the point of this thread

it is not what we are thinking (what is the right way?)

[death rose]

yeah you have to pray again =P

[Abu Eliyas]

yeah you have to pray again =P

any proof :flower:

[DODY]

xD back to islamic threads , alright umm which prayers and which call to prayers you heard ? o_O ?

ghasheem, what this stupid commentry

which prayers?al fajer
which call to prayers you heard ? al maghreb

so what calculations u gonna do now :hyper:

[Soulless]

ghasheem, what this stupid commentry

which prayers?al fajer
which call to prayers you heard ? al maghreb

so what calculations u gonna do now :hyper:


Ghasheem wa7ed -__-

well i thought that he prayed for al-3a9er then he heard , al-maghrib call , thats why i wanted to know exactly the timing of his prayers :P so i can answer him properly.

in case he prayed al-3a9er and the Red afterglow is in the skies , his prayers wouldnt be accepted whether he heard the call for al-maghrib or not.