Would you tell the police if you found out that a fellow Muslim was planning to deliberately kill women and children?

yeah i believe i would!
why wouldnt i??

Absolutely. As I said many times..I hate all criminals and criminal acts..and so them being 'muslims' doesn't change the fact that what they're doing is wrong.

Duh of course! what kinda question is that?

100% yes, if i'm sure of me.

99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999% yes

of course i would tell the police whether that guy was a muslim, a christian, Jew, a hindu, an alien, Bush, or wutever
very silly and racist question.

Not a racist question or silly
He is asking i assume, cause in this situation many Sablanians/oids in past said that since is written in Quran that we must not harm a Muslim brother/sister, then also in this case we must not report
Silly statement cause in Quran is not specified whether the Muslim we're talking about, is good or bad person but i think he/she must be a good one

i still see it a silly question. it should be more general
Muslim or non muslim it doesn't matter
nobody should kill innocents

yes I will

would u protest against your goverment if you knew that they are planning to invade a country with no good cause but greed and killing?

Yeah, if I knew something like tht was happening - how could I not tell?!

" If the police is corrupted, I will be lost"

Ofcourse I'll tell the police.

I agree with QuEeN, such a racist & silly question!

No doubt about that! I don't care about the person's religion for this matter, because what he/she is doing, is very wrong, and I'll be doing that person a favor, by banning him from committing that big sin! (I would hope so..)

I think Mr. P asked this question because some Imams in the UK have said they WOULD NOT inform the police if they knew members of their mosque were planning terrorist activities.

Not such a silly question after all.

ahaa ok ,thanks for explaining amo and wudjab

If an Imam actually says that he would help terrorists by covering up for them, then they wouldn't deserve their position of authority.

I think Mr. P asked this question because some Imams in the UK have said they WOULD NOT inform the police if they knew members of their mosque were planning terrorist activities.



Which Imams have said that?

Of course I would tell the police! Innocent lives are at stake and what if they are my relatives or something like that

i still see it a silly question. it should be more general
Muslim or non muslim it doesn't matter
nobody should kill innocents

sorry but what a question !
why is it a muslim ? y didnt u say a jew ??

well to answer.. yes id call the police !

because Jews haven't been found plotting to blow up civilian airliners or passenger trains.

Muslim or non muslim, killing people isn't from Islam and who ever planning to do so and I know it sure I will tell.

Like everyone else, I would call the police

lmao, what a stupid question.

I will call the police and also the military if I find out a fellow Muslim is planning to kill innocent people, Muslims and Non-Muslims. However, if this Muslim is one who is trying to avenge the killings of his innocent family, I will make sure I help him with what will enable him to kill those who killed his family if he does not get justice through peaceful means.

.. if i report them, then the mafia will track me down n kill me n my family!!

.. if i didnt, the bomber will kill the target!!

.. so in both cases there will be some death!!

.. SO, reasonabley, i would NOT!!

Yes i will ....:super:

Lol toomuch, you jump to conclusions pretty fast! Mafia???

because Jews haven't been found plotting to blow up civilian airliners or passenger trains.

well jews love earth n dont want to die for anything.. they would do anything to stay alive.. while muslims would do anything - in their thining - that will take them to janah.. but unfoutunatly not all muslims r doing it the right way.. but it's like party time when a mujahed bombs himself in an jewesh area!

hell yeah !!

:XD:

yeah wt a weird thread any way's !!

Would you tell the police if you found out that a fellow Muslim was planning to deliberately kill women and children?

Is this question meant to be like a survey of what the general muslims think?

because Jews haven't been found plotting to blow up civilian airliners or passenger trains.
haven't u been watchin news lately??
Israelies have been blowing up a whole country and targetting small children!

Of course I would. I don't understand how would anyone support and keep quiet towards a killer!

Would you tell the police if you found out that a fellow Muslim was planning to deliberately kill women and children?
I tell them that someone is trying to kill someone else...

because Jews haven't been found plotting to blow up civilian airliners or passenger trains.

hahaha... they are only found after its done... :p

^^^
looooooooooool dude !

they blow up an antire country n it's ok :p

yes, even is were my own biological brother. On the Day of Judgement you wouldnt want to be be complict in murder and have that on your records

Hope that answers you questions. I think Mr Pinnochio will ask another question after this...i have read a thread like this before in sabla....

of course i would...