but please in simple way.

I don't think you will get an answer form them, they have been asked 60 questions and none of them answered. :rolleyes:

Originally posted by Try2FindMe
but please in simple way.

It sure as hell isn't burying them up to their necks and then stoning them to death. :shoot:

Originally posted by TeaBagger
It sure as hell isn't burying them up to their necks and then stoning them to death. :shoot:

Ok now answer the question

Punishment is for God to decide.

Originally posted by sanwin25
Punishment is for God to decide. Correct but there are must be some verses in Cristian or Jew books.

So we are waiting for someone with the knowlege of Taurat and Injil to tell us please.

Nope.

There is no 'punishment'.

Punishment is for God.

This is Christianity, not Islam.

Have u ever thought about a wife or husband whose spose has commited adultery? (shame, Divorces, Childrens, broken house,killings etc)

In Islam in day of Judgements and sin (wrong) done to a person in his knowledge or without, Could be only forgiven buy that person.

Nope. We have no book of punishments or rules.

Punishment will come from God.

Originally posted by Nocia9600
Correct but there are must be some verses in Cristian or Jew books.
Do you find it hard to believe that other religions don't prescribe certain cruel punishments like yours does?

Originally posted by sanwin25
Punishment is for God to decide.

That is true but in the hereafter, a person who commit a sin should be punished to clear his sin in this life. Or he wants to wait until thrown in the hell fire.

Originally posted by IceTea
That is true but in the hereafter, a person who commit a sin should be punished to clear his sin in this life. Or he wants to wait until thrown in the hell fire.

As Cetacea said, when you think about other realities you must get out of your standard ways of thinking and accept the others: Christianity is different than Islam, there's not a detailed strict view like ours which does not mean is not a valid religion.

Originally posted by Cetacea
Do you find it hard to believe that other religions don't prescribe certain cruel punishments like yours does?
No we just want to know what are the punishments.




I found this on old test
(Jews)
(Leviticus chapter 20, CEV)

10 If any of you men have sex with another man's wife, both you and the woman will be put to death.




http://www.broadcaster.org.uk/section2/defence.htm

Here we go again

STONING FOR ADULTERY: CONTRADICTIONS (http://www.irfi.org/Islamic%20Articles%20Folder/stoning_for_adultery.htm)


The Bible confirms the Verses “And the man that committeth adultery with another man’s wife, even he that committeth adul_tery with his neighbor’s wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death.” (Leviticus. 20d0)

In Deuteronomy 22:23 we read the following: “If a damsel that is a virgin betrothed unto a husband, and a man find her in the city, and lie with her; then ye shall bring them both into the gate of the city, and ye shall stone them with stones that they die.”

You should have come out with that earlier instead of playing dumb all along.

We have discussed the Old Testament and New Testament several times already.

Read about what Jesus said when he stopped the group who were trying to stone an adulterous woman to death :

"Let he who is without sin cast the first stone".

To put it in simple language that you can understand "Stop being such a frigging hypocrite".

Nocia, to make it clear, the two verses you quote are from the Old Testament - the Jewish book of law.

Christians do not follow Jewish law, and Sanwin is correct about the Christian view.

The Jews are much like Islam in their detailed accounting of rules and punishments, but Christianity is different...

Originally posted by sanwin25
You should have come out with that earlier instead of playing dumb all along.

sanwin 1st ask me when I knew about this.

It is only Today 5 minutes before my post


MoonChild
Thank you for the clarification.

IF u look at my post I clearly mention JEWS. I found this on old test
(Jews)
(Leviticus chapter 20, CEV)
10 If any of you men have sex with another man's wife, both you and the woman will be put to death. [/B]

Originally posted by Nocia9600
IF u look at my post I clearly mention JEWS.
But the title of your post mentioned both Christians and Jews. You should put in a little bit of time and learn who follows which book before you come here and quote stuff from the wrong book. You also need to look at what people actually practice. I’ve never heard of Jews stoning their adulterers to death as part of their state sanctioned religious practice. A fair comparison to Islam would be if Israel or Vatican had and implemented laws to put adulterers to death like Saudi or Iran does.

You seem to be using the quote in the Bible to justify stoning in Islam, but you missed the point completely. Both the Old Testament and the Quran prescribe death for adulterers. While the Jews have abandoned such barbaric ritual, some Muslims still practice it. Care to explain why?

Originally posted by Cetacea
But the title of your post mentioned both Christians and Jews. True, The member rised this topic to know about Christians and Jews. And no body answered,

I searched and found old test for Jews and I posted.

So do u have any thing to post for Christians so we can answer Try2FindMe question:wave:

Have you read moon explanation above or just u upt something.

Oops Nocia, I thought you posted the original question and came back to answer it yourself. Sorry about that.

Originally posted by Cetacea
Care to explain why?

Because muslims respect God rules and don't keep what suit them and ignore what doesn't suit them like others do. Allah rules are not optional thing it's an order and should be followed. That is why!.

As an Orthodox Jew, I'll speak for Judaism and the Torah.

According to Judaism, adultery is a sin so severe that the death penalty should be applied. However, as explained elsewhere, the Torah is divided into the written and oral laws; the latter explains the former.

The Talmud, the central book of the oral law, explains that the death penalty only applies when the Jewish people have a Temple. Since we are waiting for the Messiah to come to rebuild it, we do not execute.

G-d, however, administers punishment to those who deserve it, "measure for measure."

However, that law only applies to Jews and Jewish courts.